Miscanthus in Alsace, pellets and solar!

crude vegetable oil, diester, bio-ethanol or other biofuels, or fuel of vegetable origin ...
freddau
I posted 500 messages!
I posted 500 messages!
posts: 641
Registration: 19/09/05, 20:08
x 1

Miscanthus in Alsace, pellets and solar!




by freddau » 23/01/08, 09:10

The building permit was signed on Monday evening in Weinbourg: by September, five hangars, 360 meters long and 22 wide, will house a unit for manufacturing pellets from biomass and will support 35 m² of photovoltaic panels. , enough to supply electricity to the nearby town of Ingwiller.

When Jean-Luc Westphal sent his letter last July requesting connection to Electricité de Strasbourg for his photovoltaic project with a power of 4,5 megawatts, the ES recalled upon receipt of the mail to "rectify the fault. Because you probably wanted to write 4,5 kilowatts, right? "

Well no, there was no confusion: the project about to be carried out at the foot of the Northern Vosges, between Weinbourg and the industrial area of ​​Ingwiller, relates to photovoltaic electricity production which is measured in MW.

It plans 35 m² of silicon panels on the roof, which would make it the largest integrated photovoltaic installation in France or even in Europe [currently, the largest integrated surface in mainland France would be located on the roof of the Geoffroy-Guichard football stadium. in Saint-Etienne with 000 m²].

At the start of this crazy gamble, a typically agricultural project. Jean-Luc Westphal who manages with his brother Daniel an essentially cereal exploitation of 200 ha wanted to diversify and produce energy from his activity.

Recovering crop residues and cutting waste

Passionate about renewable energies (the Westphal brothers were the first in 2003 to set up a cereal boiler), the farmer-entrepreneur imagined compacting corn cane and wheat straw, as well as wood waste forester of surrounding farms.

This biomass transformed into pellets and briquettes, will then be sold as fuel "for an energy yield far superior to wood". He also intends to develop crops reputed to be energetic: miscanthus, for example, also called elephant grass, from Asia, a simple crop with a yield of 15 t per hectare (compared to six for cereal straw) or even willow, short rotation wood (12 t / ha).

In the mind of Jean-Luc Westphal, this biomass will advantageously replace fuel oil: "Once processed, 2,2 kg of wheat straw is equivalent to a liter of fuel oil, for half the price". But processing at a lower cost requires natural drying and therefore significant storage capacity, sheltered from the weather.
"This is where the project combined with photovoltaics," explains the farmer. Since I had to build very large storage halls, I might as well orient them to the south and provide for silicon panels on the roof. ”

Investment amortized over eleven years

From an initial investment of 2 million euros, the project suddenly rose to 22 million, the additional cost corresponding to 35 m² of photovoltaic cells for an electrical production unit with a power of 000 MW. With the purchase price imposed for integrated photovoltaics, the return on investment is expected eleven years after the start of production.
With his file under his arm, Jean-Luc Westphal embarked on a veritable marathon, in particular with the authorities to carry out his business. "You had to see the heads of people when they took the measure of the project, reports Pierre Froeliger who as a lawyer assisted his friend in all the procedures, authorization requests, declaration of exploitation, connection requests, negotiation of supplies , etc. We can say that we wiped plasters everywhere but we hung on ».
Except with the rapidly seduced bank, we had to convince again and again that such a project, innovative but designed without a research firm and carried by a single shareholder, was viable.
Finally, all the authorizations have been obtained or are in the process of being notified and the building permit was signed Monday evening by the mayor of Weinbourg. The five buildings will soon emerge from the ground on the grounds of SAS Hanau-Energie and by September, the new unit should start its double production with at least five direct jobs.

Simone wehrung


http://www.dna.fr/local/region/20080123_DNA008813.html
0 x
User avatar
bham
Econologue expert
Econologue expert
posts: 1666
Registration: 20/12/04, 17:36
x 6




by bham » 23/01/08, 09:37

HAT !!!
0 x
Christophe
Moderator
Moderator
posts: 79332
Registration: 10/02/03, 14:06
Location: Greenhouse planet
x 11046

Re: Miscanthus in Alsace, pellets and photovoltaics!




by Christophe » 23/01/08, 10:00

Nice project but I do not see well the reason for 35 m² (€ 000 million just in PV ???) made on PV ...

The profitability of the project is therefore linked to the goodwill of Edf to buy their electricity ... (in other words: they can sink the project) ...

come from Asia, of simple cultivation and with a yield of 15 t per hectare (against six for cereal straw) or the willow, short rotation wood (12 t / ha).


Uh small rectification: for short rotation wood it is 12 t / ha every 3 years ... While miscanthus it is 15 T / ha each year (for more than 20 years) after the 2nd year ... I have plenty of docs awaiting publication on biomass and short rotation coppice.

One thing is clear: there is nothing better than Miscanthus in terms of dry matter and ease of cultivation as this document shows: Cultivation and properties of Miscanthus

But, incredible thing, the article does not even speak of the tonnage of pellets envisaged on the other hand ... which is however the basis of the project ...: Shock:

Solar energy should make more dreams than biomass ...

ps: MDR the reaction of ES ...
0 x
Christine
Grand Econologue
Grand Econologue
posts: 1144
Registration: 09/08/04, 22:53
Location: In Belgium, once
x 1




by Christine » 23/01/08, 10:39

of simple cultivation and with a yield of 15 t per hectare (compared to six for cereal straw)

Yes but with cereal straw, we have at least cereals:

- It is a diversification of income - avoids dependence on the project at the sole cost of buy-out by EDF-.

- Avoids the problem of agricultural land dedicated only to energy at the expense of food.

I would prefer that our farmers continue to feed us with more a recovery of their "waste", rather than becoming energy industrialists.
0 x
Christophe
Moderator
Moderator
posts: 79332
Registration: 10/02/03, 14:06
Location: Greenhouse planet
x 11046




by Christophe » 23/01/08, 10:52

The 2 are compatible Christine provided you do wise organic choices.

Miscanthus is a most productive terrestrial plant on dry matter so energy (combustion) ... unlike those currently used for 1st generation agrofuels like corn (energy yield on corn ethanol of 0.88 therefore less than 1 !!!).

Shall we try to organize a guided tour when this factory turns up?
0 x
Christine
Grand Econologue
Grand Econologue
posts: 1144
Registration: 09/08/04, 22:53
Location: In Belgium, once
x 1




by Christine » 23/01/08, 11:05

The problem is not the productivity and the yield of miscanthus: its yield is surely a dream for engineers on paper, but that is not a reason to replace food crops with miscanthus. Many of us prefer a good fresh bread to energetic miscanthus fibers in our plates.
0 x
Christophe
Moderator
Moderator
posts: 79332
Registration: 10/02/03, 14:06
Location: Greenhouse planet
x 11046




by Christophe » 23/01/08, 12:34

No one is talking about replacing food crops ... this may be the case for corn bioethanol but not for miscanthus ...
0 x
User avatar
loop
Grand Econologue
Grand Econologue
posts: 816
Registration: 03/10/07, 06:33
Location: Picardie




by loop » 23/01/08, 13:07

Hello

For the photovoltaic project, it would be wise to know the gray energy necessary for their manufacture until their end of life and reprocessing (if there is one) : Evil:

It is very common in the minds of the general public, to assimilate the electrical energy produced by photovoltaic cells, as a renewable energy, this forgetting to specify real ecological interest
Once again, susbventions cause an anti-ecological drift in the end : Evil:

I imagine that the cells are not produced in France
Wouldn't the interest of government aid encourage local productions, and those that consume the least amount of gray energy?
As I said in a message on another subject, photovoltaics will be green when the energy used for their production, transport, installation, maintenance and recycling is itself photovoltaic. In my opinion, it's not for tomorrow :frown:

A+
0 x
User avatar
Did67
Moderator
Moderator
posts: 20362
Registration: 20/01/08, 16:34
Location: Alsace
x 8685




by Did67 » 23/01/08, 13:52

Christophe wrote:The 2 are compatible Christine provided you do wise organic choices.

Shall we try to organize a guided tour when this factory turns up?


The article lacks precision:

- as regards wheat straw transformed into pellets, I fear, in the long term, as an agronomist, a deficit in the humic balance of the plots or the exploitation, with as possible consequences: fall of the fertility ( compensated by increasing doses of fertilizer?), decrease in the biological activity of the soils and erosion (if slopes, even weak).

- what is miscanthus? Meadows? Cereals ? Wasteland? In each case, there will be disadvantages ... Which does not mean that you should not go! If it is sustainable development, the long term must be positive!
0 x
User avatar
Did67
Moderator
Moderator
posts: 20362
Registration: 20/01/08, 16:34
Location: Alsace
x 8685

Re: Miscanthus in Alsace, pellets and photovoltaics!




by Did67 » 23/01/08, 14:00

Christophe wrote:
The profitability of the project is therefore linked to the goodwill of Edf to buy their electricity ... (in other words: they can sink the project) ...


NO ! They cannot sink. The law obliges EdF to buy at full price for 15 years (from memory). Any well-designed project is profitable before. Otherwise, a bank will never follow.

But that poses other questions.

It's exactly the same for wind turbines: why they are companies private who canvass the town halls in favorable sites and "push" the projects? Have they suddenly become green? You dream ! It is because this is a juicy market. One of the most profitable and safest investments of the moment !!!! Besides cocaine, of course ...

Subsidiary question: who pays ??? Not the state, as many believe. But the end consumer!

PS: on the one hand, it is clear that large consumers of electricity pay for the development of production from renewable resources!
0 x

 


  • Similar topics
    Replies
    views
    Last message

Back to "biofuels, biofuels, biofuels, BtL, non-fossil alternative fuels ..."

Who is online ?

Users browsing this forum : No registered users and 106 guests