The advice of a physicist

Tips, advice and tips to lower your consumption, processes or inventions as unconventional engines: the Stirling engine, for example. Patents improving combustion: water injection plasma treatment, ionization of the fuel or oxidizer.
francoisb
I discovered econologic
I discovered econologic
posts: 6
Registration: 17/09/06, 08:50
Location: Canada

The advice of a physicist




by francoisb » 17/09/06, 10:38

Hello,

I came across your forum looking for forums ecologists because ecology is a subject close to my heart.

I am a PhD student in physical engineering at the École Polytechnique de Montréal (Canada). I have a lot of respect for those who, like me, respect the planet and invest their energy to slightly improve the lot of our environment.

I really like your discussions on ecology and ecological policy. On the other hand, I was very disappointed when I went through the sections "Tips for consuming less and special motors" and "Motors or surunitary processes, debate and ideas?". First, the surunitaire, I understand that the majority of people do not believe in it, and that's good! It's completely crazy! As for engine modifications to improve fuel consumption or reduce pollution, several (surely not all) discussions are riddled with nonsense explained in language that has only scientific terms.

One point that bothered me in several discussions relates to lobbies. Indeed, lobbies are powerful. The oil companies are very well connected to the American government and have too big powers. On the other hand, to think that car manufacturers are working together not to use technologies that would reduce fuel consumption is absurd! The car manufacturers would have added your widgets! In terms of energy, there are so many millions that are spent in universities that it is impossible that the greatest researchers in this world do not find solutions that a guy would have worked out in his garage. Lobbies don't control universities like that. I've been in academia for a long time and researchers have had a lot of resources to research unsubsidized projects and trust me that a researcher who would develop a technique that would only save one percent of the gas consumption of a car would publish its discovery and become extremely rich!

I am a specialist in optics, not in mechanics, but my training in thermodynamics is still solid and I have been seriously interested in energetics since the beginning of my engineering studies. I also managed one of the first electric vehicle design projects in Canada and studied energy in Grenoble

I would have explained well why one will never be able to draw nothing from the energy of the vacuum, and why the superunitary technologies will remain only urban legends, but unfortunately do not have much time to argue on all the things which I believe badly included here. My managers are pushing me to get publications out quickly and I have already spent too much time on this forum. I am not judging you, I just find it unfortunate that such well-intentioned people harm the environment by modifying engines when they want to reduce pollution and believe in superunit machines. I only flew over your discussions very quickly, I may be wrong about the functioning and performance of the gadgets we are talking about here, but I have the impression that many people base their beliefs on urban legends.


No hard feelings,

François
0 x
Christophe
Moderator
Moderator
posts: 79120
Registration: 10/02/03, 14:06
Location: Greenhouse planet
x 10973

Re: The opinion of a physicist




by Christophe » 17/09/06, 10:45

FrançoisB wrote:that one percent of a car's gas mileage would publish its discovery and become extremely wealthy!


So this is the researchers' ultimate goal? Become extremely wealthy? : Shock: I think I missed an episode there ... is it not doing research and advancing science?

Otherwise for your info, 1% have hundreds to have (1% is not even measurable on a road vehicle) with water doping ... We are in most cases between 10 and 30% (André one of your compatriot will quickly come and confirm) ... and all this just by tinkering ... nobody seeks to become extremely rich among us, it is surely the difference between "researcher of labs" squandering their budget and us ... Which ones get things done the most? My opinion is mixed ...

Ps: are there no pressures in energy research? Ok well ask about Makhoninne, Edgard Nazar, Jean Luc Perrier ... there is info on this site about them ...

Another source: patent offices ...
0 x
User avatar
Philippe Schutt
Econologue expert
Econologue expert
posts: 1611
Registration: 25/12/05, 18:03
Location: Alsace
x 33




by Philippe Schutt » 17/09/06, 11:34

summary of the post from françoisb, paragraph by paragraph:

hello etc ...

I introduce myself ...

I like you but you are crazy ...

trust lobbies instead of searching for yourself ...

my opinion is the best because of who i am ...

I will not argue with you, I do not have time, the cash calls me ...

some don't have big heads, no no : Shock:
0 x
Other
Pantone engine Researcher
Pantone engine Researcher
posts: 3787
Registration: 17/03/05, 02:35
x 12




by Other » 17/09/06, 16:37

Hello François Bor

When you go to Sorel (not far from Montreal)
I will be able to show you a Buick Parque avenue a hurdy-gurdy, we will sail full speed, after a good tour we will refuel
and then you will argue .. She just has a turbulator and a fuel heater ..
and if you want to see a petrol engine running on (heating oil) I can make it run.
as well as two other vehicles pantonize, you think that we do that just to animate a forum ?
But I think that you come from the same school of engineers that I have trained in industry, I learned a lot from them about what happens in your schools, when you go to set foot in a factory, if you lucky to come in, there will be a guy who will guide you to explain how to live with technicians, workers and small handymen who make modifications in the factory, and who works very well.
The director of the factory told me André you have experience of the men in the factory, take care of these young people who are more tech savvy than us, but we can't let them go (loosse) like that in the 'factory, with the mentality that their school taught them there is going to be a war with the workers and the union.

Ask yourself the question
Why the Arrow plane project was dismantled and its team disbanded, even saved a prototype for the Otawa museum.
Why the auto electric motor wheel project of Couture center of search of hydro Quebec in Varenne was dissolved, the quasiturbine motor of St-Hilaire who is a researcher who was part of the Coutu team, can not pass his project in Quebec, no credit, but abroad they are interested!
Why hydroquebec does not invest in wind power, it does all the studies and installations by subcontracts.
it is all a technology and we know what is going on under our noses.
Make no mistake, what needs to be done and developed in Canada
must go through the American sensure, they are the ones who decide, and it must not be ahead of their technology or harm their economy. In your large schools they forgot to make the history of the great of the great discoveries.



You are young with time you will understand all this, and soon enough!

Andre
0 x
denis
Grand Econologue
Grand Econologue
posts: 944
Registration: 15/12/05, 17:26
Location: rhone alps
x 2




by denis » 17/09/06, 17:11

yes, welcome to the world of reality !!
0 x
White would not exist without the dark, but anyway!


http://maison-en-paille.blogspot.fr/
User avatar
nonoLeRobot
Master Kyot'Home
Master Kyot'Home
posts: 790
Registration: 19/01/05, 23:55
Location: Beaune 21 / Paris
x 13




by nonoLeRobot » 17/09/06, 17:23

: Arrow: Francois

I completely understand your impression François, I have the same.

But hey you have to sort it out, you have to see that there are a lot of people on the forum and there are a lot of wacky things but also a lot of interesting things. As for the surunitaire, I advise you not to go to this part of the forum, I haven't been there for a long time.
0 x
denis
Grand Econologue
Grand Econologue
posts: 944
Registration: 15/12/05, 17:26
Location: rhone alps
x 2




by denis » 17/09/06, 17:43

it is damage, the knowledge or instruction of the people completely block them :!: , scientists get nowhere because they are too sectarian.
This is why the gifts of clairvoyance do not exist, just like magnetism ect. : Cheesy: God does not exist :!:

a great scientific MAN who remains humble hubert reeve, he knows reality closely, because he knew how to stay open to any eventuality
the more we know the less we know ..
0 x
White would not exist without the dark, but anyway!





http://maison-en-paille.blogspot.fr/
freddau
I posted 500 messages!
I posted 500 messages!
posts: 641
Registration: 19/09/05, 20:08
x 1




by freddau » 17/09/06, 19:55

Hello Denis,

your words give me food for thought.
You still need a certain knowledge, a base doubled with a critical, humble, open-minded mind.
But these are things that are not easy to obtain because who does not feel good in a universe he knows well. You always have to question yourself and excuse me, but it is not easy, it is not our own.

For God, you startle me because for the moment it is only a belief and strangely if I tell you that I believe that my God is better than yours .... you will not believe me and it will be very confrontational .
So leave the concept of God aside, please.

Allah Akba


If FrancoisBpense thinks there are a lot of fricks in energies, he has only tested the panone.
0 x
Christophe
Moderator
Moderator
posts: 79120
Registration: 10/02/03, 14:06
Location: Greenhouse planet
x 10973




by Christophe » 17/09/06, 19:58

denis wrote:a great scientific MAN who remains humble hubert reeve, he knows reality closely, because he knew how to stay open to any eventuality. The more we know, the less we know.


In contrast there is Charpack ... for him Science is EVERYTHING (powerful) : Cheesy:

freddau wrote:If FrancoisBpense thinks there are a lot of fricks in energies, he has only tested the panone.


If so promised, there is a lot of money in the energy field but especially for those who sell them ... not those who seek to save them ...
0 x
denis
Grand Econologue
Grand Econologue
posts: 944
Registration: 15/12/05, 17:26
Location: rhone alps
x 2




by denis » 17/09/06, 21:21

freddau wrote:Hello Denis,

your words give me food for thought.
You still need a certain knowledge, a base doubled with a critical, humble, open-minded mind.
But these are things that are not easy to obtain because who does not feel good in a universe he knows well. You always have to question yourself and excuse me, but it is not easy, it is not our own.

For God, you startle me because for the moment it is only a belief and strangely if I tell you that I believe that my God is better than yours .... you will not believe me and it will be very confrontational .
So leave the concept of God aside, please.

Allah Akba


If FrancoisBpense thinks there are a lot of fricks in energies, he has only tested the panone.


I was waiting for this one : Cheesy: : Cheesy: God?? which : Cheesy:
what I mean is that we can't prove it, nor the opposite!
and the difference of several gods must be thought of! . It is not in my mind. You confuse with religion, there are many! and there are still wars because of that : Shock:
hubert R. one day spoke about it he believes in ... ( : Cheesy: ) but not a guy with a white or black beard with the cane. Only something that the human mind cannot imagine, like the infinity of the cosmos, although nothing is proven
0 x
White would not exist without the dark, but anyway!





http://maison-en-paille.blogspot.fr/

Back to "Special motors, patents, fuel consumption reduction"

Who is online ?

Users browsing this forum : No registered users and 158 guests