A commercial solar panel, with tempered glass glazing, aluminum frame, copper absorber, etc ... cost about 120 € m²
I already self-built a panel and it worked pretty well ... in the summer (see in the history of my messages) but last year I also installed a CESI with serious hardware trade.
Perso between a panel tinked with ugly, limited performance, and limited life (wood, greenhouse tarpaulin) to 25 € m² and a trick that will hold 25 years without the slightest maintenance and that I can ask on my roof without my neighbors take me for a manouche 120 € m², my choice is made ... (and I repeat that I have already tried the 2)
Especially as I have already noted, in a solar thermal installation, the price of the panels does not necessarily represent a big part of the cost of the installation. My CESI cost me in the end about 6000 € including 650 € panels ... I let you do the ratio and judge if it is really profitable to s'em ...... to make them even.
solar heating autoconstruction
Re: Solar heating in self-construction
I copy the approach I follow for CESI.
120 euros / m2 it's reasonable.
I specify that 25 euros / m2 is with polycarbonate plate and EPDM in SSC large dimension well integrated in the ground not so ugly but it is subjective (good DIY perspective).
http://www.builditsolar.com/Experimenta ... gTest2.htm
Lilian
120 euros / m2 it's reasonable.
I specify that 25 euros / m2 is with polycarbonate plate and EPDM in SSC large dimension well integrated in the ground not so ugly but it is subjective (good DIY perspective).
http://www.builditsolar.com/Experimenta ... gTest2.htm
Lilian
0 x
- chatelot16
- Econologue expert
- posts: 6960
- Registration: 11/11/07, 17:33
- Location: Angouleme
- x 264
Re: Solar heating in self-construction
to make economics you have to put the price
a cheap thing that gets torn down with every gust of wind or hail is not the best way to save money
Tempered glass has 2 advantage
1) it supports the thermal shock much better than the ordinary glass: tempered glass is made the oven door or the halogen lamp windows
2) it has a mechanical strength much greater than ordinary glass: so it easily resists the hail ... when there is a big blow of hail all the greenhouse with ordinary glass are broken: the tempered glass of the cars and solar collector resist well
try to break a tempered glass car: it's spectacular: it gives a hammer that would break any ordinary glass and it does not break ... of course we ended up typing hard enough and manage to break it
tempered glass is only ordinary glass with a heat treatment: it does not cost much more than regular glass ... except trade problem that always wants to try to make expensive what is out of the ordinary
it would be necessary to make a solar oven to soak the glass for free!
a cheap thing that gets torn down with every gust of wind or hail is not the best way to save money
Tempered glass has 2 advantage
1) it supports the thermal shock much better than the ordinary glass: tempered glass is made the oven door or the halogen lamp windows
2) it has a mechanical strength much greater than ordinary glass: so it easily resists the hail ... when there is a big blow of hail all the greenhouse with ordinary glass are broken: the tempered glass of the cars and solar collector resist well
try to break a tempered glass car: it's spectacular: it gives a hammer that would break any ordinary glass and it does not break ... of course we ended up typing hard enough and manage to break it
tempered glass is only ordinary glass with a heat treatment: it does not cost much more than regular glass ... except trade problem that always wants to try to make expensive what is out of the ordinary
it would be necessary to make a solar oven to soak the glass for free!
0 x
Re: Solar heating in self-construction
Another parameter to take into account in the price is also the efficiency of the sensor.
If a commercial sensor 120 € / m² at a yield of 60% but that the thing is even 25 € / m² at a yield of 30% only, well put 2m ² sensor collocated where 1m ² of the trade is enough. So with equal heating power we no longer compare 25 € and 120 € but 50 € and 120 €
(It's numbers to illustrate the example, I do not really have a precise idea on the values of the yields of different types of sensors)
If a commercial sensor 120 € / m² at a yield of 60% but that the thing is even 25 € / m² at a yield of 30% only, well put 2m ² sensor collocated where 1m ² of the trade is enough. So with equal heating power we no longer compare 25 € and 120 € but 50 € and 120 €
(It's numbers to illustrate the example, I do not really have a precise idea on the values of the yields of different types of sensors)
0 x
Re: Solar heating in self-construction
I had made syntheses of experience feedback and other measurements made by me.
I get power and energy values back to the panel's production price.
The glazed EPDM that was not insulated at the back showed very good performance.
.
We notice by a temperature of 0 ° outside that the panel is 40% more powerful brought back to the blow of production
I get power and energy values back to the panel's production price.
The glazed EPDM that was not insulated at the back showed very good performance.
.
We notice by a temperature of 0 ° outside that the panel is 40% more powerful brought back to the blow of production
0 x
Re: Solar heating in self-construction
What is not evaluated of course is the durability and the time spent to achieve it.
0 x
Re: Solar heating in self-construction
Hello,
I wanted to test their method with PP panels, but impossible to find a store that sells it!
Do you have an idea?
Have a good day,
freD.
I wanted to test their method with PP panels, but impossible to find a store that sells it!
Do you have an idea?
Have a good day,
freD.
0 x
Re: Solar heating in self-construction
For the sides, they seem to use rails for partition placo ... it is galvanized at least this stuff?
0 x
Re: Solar heating in self-construction
Yes the rails and uprights for the placo are galvanized. As against all that is galvanized, if we cut or pierce, we lose the protection at the machining ...
0 x
Re: Solar heating in self-construction
Ok
It's interesting to tinker with stuff out of the box ...
Must make panels of 3m then ;-)
That's good, I need horizontal panels.
It's interesting to tinker with stuff out of the box ...
Must make panels of 3m then ;-)
That's good, I need horizontal panels.
0 x
-
- Similar topics
- Replies
- views
- Last message
-
- 1 Replies
- 5642 views
-
Last message by sicetaitsimple
View the latest post
13/09/20, 15:01A subject posted in the forum : Solar thermal: solar collectors CESI, heating, hot water, stoves and solar cookers
-
- 5 Replies
- 6889 views
-
Last message by Thursday63
View the latest post
06/12/20, 10:09A subject posted in the forum : Solar thermal: solar collectors CESI, heating, hot water, stoves and solar cookers
-
- 0 Replies
- 5773 views
-
Last message by tribalwar
View the latest post
29/03/19, 21:12A subject posted in the forum : Solar thermal: solar collectors CESI, heating, hot water, stoves and solar cookers
-
- 0 Replies
- 5906 views
-
Last message by Dudule
View the latest post
15/11/17, 00:14A subject posted in the forum : Solar thermal: solar collectors CESI, heating, hot water, stoves and solar cookers
-
- 3 Replies
- 5757 views
-
Last message by Christophe
View the latest post
22/08/17, 13:23A subject posted in the forum : Solar thermal: solar collectors CESI, heating, hot water, stoves and solar cookers
Back to "Solar thermal: solar collectors CESI, heating, hot water, stoves and solar cookers"
Who is online ?
Users browsing this forum : No registered users and 96 guests