nico239 wrote:
As I said above pheno-perma and co ... it's not ready to reproduce or ready to plant but ready to adapt to its context ... which is not quite the same
I would be much much more severe. It is first a fashion, and then a religion. With what that entails as dogma and idiocy (when you don't believe it). Even in the name of a good philosophy. But Christianity is also based on "good principles". And ended up in religious wars or in inquisition, in forced conversion of the "savages", before settling down a little ... [I am talking about the social phenomenon "religion", and not about "faith", which is an individual fact, which I respect, even if I regret that believers need such crutches to live]
We have never seen a natural mechanism making mounds, any more than spirals. No plant grows better in a spiral or a keyhole! It doesn't make sense to start by messing up or killing everything in the name of natural gardening. It is even shocking and to wonder about the intellectual capacities of man! And burying fermentable organic matter (this is not the case with wood) as I sometimes see it, is quite simply to make a methaniser ... Of course, "it works". Like conventional agriculture, which still produces 95% of our food (despite the fact that everyone eats "organic", according to the impression we have; 2015 data!)
I don't know why, maybe this confused feeling of witnessing a vast swindle, but it annoys me! It is not enough to oppose something "bad" to be in the "good"!